Table 5: Summary of results for FX102x9 problem for FTMATM experiments.

 

FTMmax = 18 flights

FTMmax = 16 flights

FTMmax = 14 flights

FTMmax = 12 flights

ATMyax

3000 min.

2700 min

2400 min

3000 min.

2700 min.

2400 min.

3000 min.

2700 min.

2400 min.

3000 min.

2700 min

2400 min

Tail No.

NFlts

Time

NFlts

Time

 NFlts

Time

NFlts

Time

NFlIts

Time

NFlts

Time

NFlts

Time

NFlts

Time

NFlts

Time

 NFlts

Time

NFlts

Time

NFlts

Time

A01

8

1710

7

1890

10

2055

11

1995

6

1895

7

1960

6

2265

7

1960

8

1950

7

2235

8

1925

12

1919

A02

10

2425

13

2198

13

2240

14

2334

11

2410

12

2354

9

2444

9

2450

11

2379

11

2400

12

2334

11

2240

A03

6

1680

8

1845

9

1509

8

1805

10

1699

9

1780

9

1125

9

1690

14

1719

10

1470

12

1880

12

1734

A04

7

1225

7

1225

7

1225

8

1200

8

1185

8

1175

10

1115

10

1075

8

1185

9

1125

10

1075

9

1105

A05

9

1625

6

1895

8

1840

8

2029

7

2050

9

1555

8

2029

7

1870

10

1759

10

2164

12

19680

7

2054

A06

11

2025

6

1865

12

2019

6

1865

9

1950

8

1959

8

1670

8

2214

6

1855

9

1740

8

2025

12

1985

A07

13

1988

14

1584

12

2129

12

1944

15

2028

12

2129

14

1794

13

1859

13

1848

11

2154

11

2154

12

1939

A08

14

1860

15

1995

15

2175

16

2140

13

2070

13

2220

14

2055

14

1859

14

2185

12

1765

12

1760

12

1770

A09

11

2338

10

2345

8

1685

9

1825

11

2169

7

2125

12

2040

9

1994

9

1840

12

2299

12

2370

10

2040

A10

9

1815

11

1785

12

1885

11

1655

13

1839

9

1430

13

1750

10

1785

14

2060

11

2174

11

2075

12

2149

A11

12

2405

13

2375

13

2370

14

2340

14

1960

12

2250

13

2385

12

2405

13

2215

12

2100

12

2105

11

1945

A12

16

2395

17

2360

16

2364

16

2210

15

2425

16

2325

14

2290

14

2090

14

2295

12

1930

12

2405

12

2040

A13

9

1730

13

2220

12

2329

10

2355

15

2398

12

2205

12

2480

14

2450

13

2399

11

2404

11

2499

11

2134

A14

13

2075

13

2145

12

1955

9

2270

9

1865

12

2105

9

1875

11

2205

9

1865

12

2100

11

1725

11

2120

A15

11

1850

12

2149

11

2104

11

2270

9

2320

11

2259

13

2194

13

1799

11

2274

12

2120

9

1915

11

2265

A16

10

2294

10

1880

7

1675

11

1745

10

1875

12

2099

12

2234

9

2400

8

2055

10

2395

9

2425

11

2250

Al7

7

1173

6

1233

7

1214

7

1229

7

1260

8

1220

8

1180

8

1170

7

1234

9

1095

10

1625

10

1620

A18

6

1670

9

1405

6

1855

10

1500

9

1390

10

1370

6

1670

10

1665

6

1670

12

1614

10

1783

9

1765

A19

9

1185

8

1180

8

1225

10

1059

8

1149

8

1189

8

1230

9

1200

9

1150

12

1585

9

1180

9

1180

A20

10

2090

8

2139

9

2060

12

2069

8

1720

14

2000

10

1690

11

1819

10

1850

12

1905

12

2065

9

2125

A21

13

 1540

12

1395

13

1530

10

1300

11

1425

12

1534

13

1484

12

1405

12

1539

11

1425

11

1430

12

1560

A22

12

2048

11

2154

11

2169

12

2139

14

2084

12

2153

10

1889

14

2078

11

2169

10

1874

12

1693

12

2123

A23

17

2350

17

2110

16

2175

15

2440

16

2369

15

2275

14

2269

14

2465

14

2075

12

2055

12

1570

12

2255

A24

11

2405

10

2260

11

2259

8

2575

11

2240

8

2205

14

2430

10

2509

12

2330

11

2499

11

2523

11

2315

A25

12

2250

11

2289

9

2120

10

2158

9

1939

10

2390

11

2359

10

1995

11

2180

12

2253

12

2015

10

1884

A26

16

2124

15

2354

16

2339

13

1779

16

2154

13

2248

13

2064

14

2254

14

2229

12

1824

12

1979

12

1824

A27

13

2055

13

2375

14

2174

13

2385

12

2410

15

2320

14

2335

13

1895

13

2220

11

1955

11

1950

12

2110

A28

11

2393

11

2073

9

2044

12

2198

10

2454

12

1889

9

2378

12

2163

12

2194

11

2064

12

2278

12

2273

Ave.

10.9

1954

10.9

1954

10.9

1954

10.9

1954

10.9

1954

10.9

1954

109

1954

109

1954

10.9

1954

109

1954

109

1954

10.9

1954

Max.

17

2425

17

2375

 16

2370

16

2575

16

2454

16

2390

14

2480

14

2509

14

2399

12

2499

12

2523

12

2315

% at Max

0%

 

0%

 

0%

 

7%

 

7%

 

4%

 

21%

 

21%

 

21%

 

43%

 

46%

 

46%

 

Std. Dev.

2.88

381.4

3.2

376.1

2.94

348.4

262

406.3

2.93

388.7

2.54

387.3

2.6

427.8

2.31

397.9

2.58

352.4

1.27

370.4

1.3

368.4

1.33

305.7

 Z

84

 

84

 

84

 

84

 

84

 

84

 

a4

 

84

 

84

 

76

 

76

 

76